Indian Idol – Why zero sum game?

I am hooked to Indian Idol this season as well but what causes a lot of uncomfort to me is the fact that Indian Idol ( and all other singing talent show in so many other languages)  is a zero sum game. There are many forces driving such a show – discovery for new talent, reality induced TRP leading to pricey ad inventory, mobile based revenue stream but none of these reasons I think are causal enough for it to be zero sum then why is it  hit driven ?

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Indian Idol – Why zero sum game?

  1. I guess people always want a victor and a celebrity. That’s what kind of creates “reality” in these shows. Doesn’t it?

    Also, it’s not actually a zero sum game. They get popularity. They get their makeover, Get to wear designer clothes 🙂 They are participating in more shows. They are finding more assignments. They are anchoring shows. I don’t think Indian Idol 3 winner Prashanth Tamang really did win as much as others did. It looks like those who have impressed organizers and judges the most, will end up in a better position than those who just impressed the junta.

  2. @gubbi
    Your first point definitely makes sense.

    The reason I say it is zero sum because it is the so called winner ( only one) who gets a singing contract or other disproportionate opportunities and while others don’t. Actually I am also expressing doubts if the others are better off due to their exposure at these shows. Whatever others get does not seem to be significant enough.

    Rajan

  3. Hi,
    we are a startup http://www.hyperwebenable.com based on silicon valley.
    providing next generation blogging service.
    We are looking to promote our blogging service for the bloggers
    we have seen your blog its very interesting we request to write paid
    review about our service in your blog it will be useful to all your
    readers .
    Please let us know how send the payment to you for the review.
    We will be happy to provide more info about our service.
    Thanks and regards
    ravi
    hyperwebenable.com

    About us

    HyperWebEnable.com is next generation blogging service provider.It
    provide free website for the bloggers rather than sub domain.

    hyperwebenable.com is distinct blogging service by providing blogger a
    complete web domain(yoursitename.com) of their choice instead of sub
    domain (yoursitename.blogspot.com).
    Hyperwebenable.com do not charge any money for any of there services
    like registration, and renewal and other services, This is a great
    opportunity for bloggers to create there own identity on the Internet.
    Bloggers can extend the blog by providing more services like Forum,CMS
    or Image servies along with the blog.

    Currently Bloggers face the problem of acquiring a website. The
    present blog services provide subdomain for the bloggers and but other
    paid services blogger have to pay for site name, space and hosting.
    HyperWebEnable.com understand the time and cost involved with this
    activity. It address the problem by providing all these services FREE
    for bloggers.It help these users through blog/website building process
    also. Bloggers can generate their own revenue by allowing them to
    place their own ads in other space available on the website/blog.

    Bloggers can get maximum out of there blog by getting these service
    1. Free website of your choice (yoursitename.com)
    2. Free Email service for the blog
    3. Free Multi flavored blogs for your blog like (tech.yoursite.com,
    movies.yoursite.com and more)
    4. Get add on services for your blog at Free like (Forum,CMS, image
    hosting and more)
    5. Unlimited bandwidth .
    6. All the services are free like domain, hosting, renewal.
    7. Tools and tips to improve your site rank and traffic.
    8. Blogger earn money by placing his own ads in the blog.

    Grab your free blog @ http://www.hyperwebenable.com

  4. Hi Rajan,
    Nice blog you have got, May I know the best possible way to contact you (you id) Wanted to send some info about our website and was wondering if you could write about us.
    Will look forward.

    Sneh

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s